On the 1st July 2008 it was announced in Bordeaux that the 2006 St Emilion Classification was invalid, and châteaux were required to remove the classifications of Premier Grand Cru Classé A or B, or Grand Cru Classé from wine labels dating from the 2006 vintage.

On the one hand this ruling is extremely disappointing and potentially confusing for consumers. The St Emilion appellation, unlike that of the Médoc, is at least dynamic in that every 10 years there are opportunities for promotion and relegation. Properties which demonstrate marked improvement are rewarded, while those who rest on their laurels risk demotion. This can be a useful safeguard against complacency and a genuine spur to improvement in quality.

On the other hand it is imperative that the assessment of the wines must be seen to be carried out in an objective and impartial manner if the classification is to be widely respected as a true reflection of the current status of properties in the St Emilion appellation. As this appears to be the stumbling block at the moment it should not be too difficult to amend the procedure so as to overcome the Court’s misgivings.